Just a Little Common Sense

For a life based on reason, ethics, literature and art.

About ‘Everybody Draw Muhammad Day’

with 3 comments

Afghan depiction of Muhammad, 1436

Afghan depiction of Muhammad, 1436

I’m all for free speech, but I think Draw Muhammad Day is a silly idea. I think so because all it does is to play into the hands of hate-mongerers on both sides. My problem here is not that it does antagonize, but that it doesn’t do anything but antagonize.The one thing that criticism of Islam always has to be careful about is not to be hijacked by xenophobes. It is too easy to get pushed into the ‘ignorant-racist-redneck-corner’, and once in there, it’s hard to get out. Criticism of Islam needs to distinguish itself from islamophobic propaganda and racist hate-mongering. We are not Islamophobes, we are rational people standing up for our rights and against censorship.
Draw Muhammad Day is sending out all the wrong signals. What it really does is to play into the hands of the more moronic fractions on both sides. On the Muslim side we will have extremists using this to demonize us in the eyes of new recruits: ‘Those westerners, look at how hatefull they are and how they lack the slightest respect!’ On our side, we will have the racists using it for the same thing: ‘Oh, look at those evil freedom-hating muslims: they already shut down Facebook to censor a few cartoons, I wonder when they will burn the next embassy?’ Both these groups will welcome Draw Muhammad Day. It is oil to their fires.

The third group are also important: The indifferent, the unaware, the undecided. The average american and european citizen. To them, this will appear to be an act of blatant, childish disrespect (which it is) and will serve to change the public perception of free-speech activists for the worse. It will result in our cause being taken less seriously, just as if we are just another maniac, cult-like fringe group out there. Draw Muhammad Day is cutting into our own flesh.

What we need is rational discourse and education. Spread links to the Muhammad Image Archive (also linked in the sidebar) to make people realize that throughout history, it has never been a sacrilege to depict the prophet of islam, not even in islamic countries. Tell them that SouthPark has already depicted Muhammad in 2001, without causing censorship, nor protests. Make the protestors look like the foolish hate-mongerers that they are, ignorant of the history of their own culture.

But no, instead we do a Draw Muhammad Day. Which means we accept the muslim extremists’ proposal that depicting the prophet constitutes sacrilege, and then gleefully commit that sacrilege, just to annoy them. It is a shocking admission of total helplessness: It’s like that kid that eats all of the chocolate today, just to show mommy that he won’t get sick from doing so.

Advertisements

Written by Phil

May 19, 2010 at 18:36

3 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. The bigger question is WHY ????….why at the first instance initiate an act which has intimate feelings by another group…Im positive there are numerous subjects available in the world which can prove freedom of speech and liberty….JEWS all over the world react to denial of holocaust ..a stance which is accepted by the world…so why not apply similar format for muslims…what really is intended to be achieved from this act or where the quality of life will improve…in actual it will fuel anti west sentiments and make the task of mopderate muslims difficult in containing militancy….

    mahmud

    May 20, 2010 at 13:27

  2. As I said, it is an admission of helplessness. People are feeling angry that their freedom of speech is so readily censored by the western media, and they feel muslims are responsible for it. So they do silly stuff like Draw Muhammad Day. They just don’t know what else to do, so they react in this childish way.

    Holocaust-denial plays in a different league alltogether. There are literally no deniers in the western world, and those few that there are are ridiculed by the media. There is no respect for this stance. Only in the middle east this kind of statement is accepted at all.

    And don’t get me wrong: I am not driven by respect for hurt muslim feelings. I do not think there should be ‘respect’ towards the silly rule of ‘do not draw our prophet’. It’s a rule that deserves no repsect, for it is only a picture. What can possibly be wrong with drawing a picture? What harm can come from it?

    I oppose Draw Mohammed Day solely because it is counterproductive.

    Ochiudo

    May 20, 2010 at 14:10

  3. @ mahmud
    how in god/mohammeds/FSMs -name can u speak about respect and in the same post compare a historically proved massacre which cost ~6billion peoples life with drawing an image?
    freedom of speech finds its boarders in spreading wrong information which mislead people. can u tell me how a drawing will mislead someone?

    the misterious potato-chip

    June 8, 2010 at 14:10


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: